FDA told pain pump manufacturers 'no,' but they refused to listen

April 29th, 2009 by Jennifer Walker-Journey

shoulderjoint 00023587 100x100Manufacturers of pain pumps were denied approval by the Food and Drug Administration (FDA) to use the devices in a different manner than what had been previously approved by the FDA for shoulder surgery. But that didn’t stop the manufacturers from advising physicians to use the devices improperly. That improper use has lead to a painful and debilitating condition in many shoulder surgery patients.

are devices that hold pain medication that is gradually released into the shoulder tissue through a catheter implanted in the surgical site. Once the pain medication has been released into the joint, the catheter is removed by the patient. When used properly, offer a convenient alternative to oral or intravenous painkillers for those undergoing shoulder surgery. And most patients can expect a good recovery following physical therapy.

However, in the late 1990s manufacturers of sought FDA approval to have the catheters placed directly in the joint area, rather than the shoulder tissue. “To the FDA’s credit, they said no,” says Frank Woodson, shareholder with Beasley Allen Law Firm. “The FDA said, ‘If you want permission to do that, you’re going to have to do safety studies to determine whether or not that is a safe practice or a safe method to use your product.’ The companies did not do that and just went ahead and started advising physicians to place the pain pump catheter in the joint space.

“They never studied it and they never obtained FDA approval,” he says. As a result, physicians began seeing their patients with a debilitating condition called chondrolysis, or a narrowing of the cartilage. As the cartilage begins to wear away, bone rubs against bone causing pain and disability. In many cases, shoulder replacement is required.

Approximately 140 have been filed in state and federal courts against manufacturers of devices and several cases are set for trial in 2009. “I hope this litigation will continue to educate the medical community to use in a proper manner because if it is done in that way, then we should stop seeing these injuries occur,” Woodson said.

blog comments powered by Disqus

Comments are moderated and generally will be posted if they are on-topic and not abusive.